The Danger of Purchasing with Payments

A coworker of Mr. Mt was selling his Honda Civic so he could find a girlfriend. He was rather sure, that with a nicer car, he would no longer be single. His Honda was almost paid off (just $3,500 left) and we took it off his hands for that price. He took out another loan for a $28k car. And he still didn’t get a girlfriend. (shocking, right?)


At the time, we had about $28,000 in the bank. There was no way we would have spent our entire savings on a new car.  We had worked so hard to get out from under $50,000 of debt. We were just starting to see our savings really grow. Our income was low, but we were stashing away $100 here or $400 there. Keeping our expenses super low and trying to save as much as we could.

Although this coworker had almost no savings, he was willing to spend $28,000 he didn’t have.

I found this really curious when the coworker took out that loan. If he would have had the $28,000, would he still have spent that amount?

If we could only spend cash that we had already saved for large purchases, how would that change our purchasing?

Here are a few of the dangers I see with buying with payments.

  1. You haven’t yet felt the pain of earning or saving the money. Why do people with the stacks of cash refuse to buy those fancy, shiny things? They know how blasten hard it was to stack all that cash! Earning it was hard. Slowly stashing it away in a bank account was hard. Having already felt that pain, there is a greater appreciation for the cash.
  2. You don’t feel the pain of biting the bullet. Handing over that pile of hundred dollar bills is a bit painful. Especially if it’s 280 $100 bills! Ouch. Never mind the fact that you will have to pay all that, plus interest if you take out a loan. You feel like you walked away with a brand new car for $1500 down plus something in the future. Whatever that is. You aren’t even really thinking about that. Just the $1500 down and shiny new car to show off and enjoy.
  3. You don’t think your future self will mind the payments. “$400 a month doesn’t sound too bad.” “I can probably swing this, right?” “It might make things a bit tighter, but it will be worth it!” Here is the thing: If your past self didn’t want to set aside $400 a month for the last 60 months, your future self won’t want to either! Think about all the months you didn’t want to save $400 for a new car. Your future months will have the same excuses the past months had.

In the end, you might spend a lot more on a car if you are spending money you don’t yet have.

If you have exactly $28k in your checking account, is that how much you would pay for a car if a loan wasn’t an option?

I have to admit, I’m a little glad that coworker sold us his Honda. We scored a sweet deal using just 10% of our savings. And have continued to drive that lovely little car all over the US and Europe for the last 11 years including during my month long YOLO US road trip.

Marketers would love for us to view the cost of large ticket items in terms of the monthly payments. But that is only beneficial to their bottom line, not yours.

Please note: I reserve the right to delete comments that are offensive or off-topic.

Add to the conversation! Community is built in the comments section. It's like free donuts after Church.

6 thoughts on “The Danger of Purchasing with Payments

  1. I have a theory that the real estate market surged in 2015-2016 because of the monthly payment mentality. Interest rates continued to collapse bc of the European troubles and mortgage rates fell as well. With the increased ability to make higher payments, consumers pushed up the price of housing, which could crash if higher interest rates ever become reality.

    • Totally agree! I think the payment idea is so much worst with house buying. Most people really have no intention of living in a place for 30 years or ever paying the house off, so the monthly payment is the only focus. The low interest rates have definitely pushed up the cost of housing. Thanks for always having such great comments!

  2. “If you have exactly $28k in your checking account, is that how much you would pay for a car if a loan wasn’t an option?”

    EXACTLY! This is the way I wish everyone would think about it. I know far too many people making good money who cannot for the life of them save enough to buy a car with cash, yet they have no problem signing up for monthly payments on exorbitant luxury vehicles. It just feels so backwards. Like you said, it’s a lot easier to sign up for $500 a month than it is to bite the bullet and feel tens of thousands of dollars leaving your checking account at once.

    • I just had a conversation with someone who for the 1st time in 15 years paid off all their car loans. They were SO happy not to have a car payment. Crazy me, asked “So are you going to start setting that money aside so you can pay cash for your next car?” They looked at me like I was insane! “No, we are going to use it to take on a bigger house payment.” (Forehead slap)
      If I’m lying, I’m dying. I never ceased to be amazed! Thanks for stopping by, and enjoy your Europe travels!

  3. Great article! I’m shopping for this type of vehicle right now! Do you mind sharing how many miles the car had when you got it. At that price point my only concern is most of the vehicles are 100k miles+.